Two wills can tell two very different stories about the same family.
In 2012, Billy Washington signed a will naming his daughter Ava as his beneficiary. Four years later, while receiving hospice care for terminal cancer, he signed another will naming his longtime girlfriend Margaret Victoria as his primary beneficiary. Billy died four days after signing it.
The documents led to a dispute in a Harris County probate court. In 2026, a Texas appellate court examined what the jury had been allowed to hear. Its decision offers a careful lesson about late-life wills: the date on a document is only the beginning of the inquiry.
A family dispute over two wills
According to the First Court of Appeals' opinion in Washington v. Victoria, the probate court initially admitted the 2012 will. Margaret then sought to probate the 2016 will. Ava contested the later document, alleging that her father lacked testamentary capacity when he signed it and that it was the product of undue influence.
At trial, a jury found that Billy had testamentary capacity when he signed the later will and that it was not the result of undue influence. The trial court entered a judgment on the verdict. Ava appealed; she did not appeal the jury's undue-influence finding.
Those are the positions and findings described in the appellate opinion. The appellate court did not decide that every allegation made during the dispute was true.
What does capacity mean?
Texas Estates Code Section 251.001 requires a person making a will to be of sound mind and to meet an age or other qualifying status specified in the statute. The appellate opinion describes testamentary capacity as a person's mental ability at the time of signing to understand, among other things, that they are making a will, its effect, the general nature of their property and the people who might naturally be considered in their plan.
A serious illness or hospice care, by itself, does not answer all of those questions. Evidence may point in different directions. In this case, the appellate court reviewed the trial record and concluded that legally sufficient evidence supported the jury's finding of capacity. That was a ruling under a particular standard of review, based on the evidence then before the court.
Why the court sent the case back
Free Guide
Texas Probate Timeline Guide
Answer a few questions, then see the next steps that may fit your situation
The jury heard testimony about Billy's alleged anger toward Ava concerning money moved from an account. Ava sought to present evidence about a power of attorney and her contention that Billy had directed the transfer and later forgotten doing so. Those circumstances were disputed; the appellate opinion does not establish the proposed account as a fact.
The appellate court concluded that, after the jury heard the other side's evidence about the incident and Billy's reaction, excluding Ava's responsive evidence was an abuse of discretion. The court also concluded that the exclusion was harmful because the evidence was important to the capacity question and might have affected the judgment.
The court reversed the trial court's judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings. It did not declare that Billy lacked capacity or identify a final winner of the will dispute. The appellate docket records that the mandate issued July 3, 2026; the sources reviewed for this article do not establish the later trial-court outcome.
The lesson is not that every piece of evidence must be admitted in every will contest. Evidence rules, the issues presented and the record matter. Here, the excluded material mattered in light of the evidence the jury had already heard and the particular question it had to decide.
When a will changes late in life
Families handling a possible probate dispute can take practical steps that help counsel understand what happened:
- Keep the documents together. Preserve earlier and later wills, amendments and the envelopes or records showing when they were found. Do not write on or alter an original.
- Make a timeline. Note the signing dates, the date of death and when each document came to light. Separate what you personally observed from what someone else told you.
- Identify useful records and witnesses. An attorney can assess relevant signing witnesses, communications, powers of attorney, financial records and medical records that may be lawfully available.
- Avoid assuming the outcome. A changed beneficiary, illness or a family disagreement alone does not establish whether a particular will is valid. Capacity and any claim of undue influence involve different questions.
- Seek guidance promptly. The correct procedure and any applicable deadlines depend on the estate and the kind of challenge being considered.
A careful review begins with the actual documents and a full account of the circumstances. Learn about WG Law's probate services and estate planning. To discuss your situation, call 214-250-4407 or contact our North Texas team.
This article provides general legal information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Texas law and individual circumstances can affect the result.

