A court investigator's report, described on page 5 of the court's opinion, said that Jelitthza Lopez-Reta had expressed a desire to attend community college. The report also described daily activities she could do and areas in which she needed help. Her family and professionals differed over how much support she needed and whether a guardian should be appointed.
Her case involved a young adult with an intellectual disability—not an older adult. Yet the legal question also arises in elder-law planning: what help is available before a court gives someone else authority to make decisions?
In January 2026, an El Paso court of appeals reviewed the evidence in Guardianship of Lopez-Reta. Its answer illustrates both the importance of considering alternatives and the fact that an alternative must fit the person's actual circumstances.
A family faced different assessments
Jelitthza's mother applied to become guardian of her person. Her father opposed the application. A court investigator described abilities Jelitthza had and recommended exploring a supported decision-making agreement. A physician's report identified some areas of ability and some limitations; a psychiatrist reached a more restrictive conclusion about her capacity.
After hearing testimony and considering the evidence, the probate court appointed her mother as permanent guardian of her person. The father appealed, challenging both the incapacity finding and the conclusion that alternatives were not feasible.
The court of appeals acknowledged conflicting evidence. Applying its standard of review, it held that the probate court did not abuse its discretion and affirmed the appointment. The decision concerned guardianship of the person; the application did not seek guardianship of Jelitthza's estate.
The appellate court concluded that the evidence supported the trial court's finding that the proposed alternatives and supports were not feasible on this record. It did not hold that supported decision-making or other alternatives are unsuitable for everyone. The official docket shows that a mandate was issued on March 13, 2026.
The legal question beneath the family question
A guardianship can affect important personal rights. Texas law therefore requires specific findings before a court appoints a permanent guardian.
Free Guide
Elder Law Planning Workbook
Essential steps for protecting aging parents in Texas
Under Texas Estates Code Section 1101.101, the court must find by clear and convincing evidence, among other things, that alternatives to guardianship and available supports and services that would avoid the appointment were considered and determined not to be feasible. The court must also make the other findings required by law. What is feasible depends on the person, the decision, the evidence and the proposed support.
The Estates Code lists possible alternatives, including medical and durable powers of attorney, representative payees for public benefits, certain trusts and other person-centered decision-making arrangements. These are examples to evaluate, not a checklist that works for every family. Some require the adult to have the capacity to understand and authorize the arrangement.
A supported decision-making agreement is another option for an eligible adult with a disability. Under Texas law, a supporter may help the adult understand information and communicate decisions; the supporter does not make those decisions for the adult. The agreement must be entered voluntarily, and whether it is appropriate depends on the person's circumstances.
Questions families can bring to the table
If an aging parent or another adult needs help, start with the person's own wishes and the decisions that actually need attention:
- What can the person do with support? Consider specific tasks, such as understanding a medical choice, paying bills or arranging transportation.
- What help already exists? Gather relevant powers of attorney, trust documents and information about trusted family members or services.
- What decisions remain difficult? Ask whether the concern involves health care, residence, finances or another area; different tools may address different needs.
- Is a less restrictive option appropriate and available? Discuss the person's ability to understand and authorize any proposed arrangement, and whether it would meet the identified need.
- If guardianship is necessary, what scope is needed? A court can consider the person's actual limitations and the authority appropriate to the situation.
These questions are useful starting points, not a substitute for an individualized legal and medical assessment. An adult's diagnosis, age or need for assistance does not by itself answer every legal question.
WG Law helps North Texas families discuss elder-law planning and guardianship options, as well as estate planning. To talk about your circumstances, call 214-250-4407 or contact our team.
This article provides general legal information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Texas law and individual circumstances can affect the result.

