What is the Best Asset Protection Tool in Texas?

In a case where a man worth $400 million, serving as Chief Financial Officer, commits fraud, leading to the bankruptcy of his company, the consequences are devastating. His actions resulted in thousands of employees losing their pensions and hundreds facing financial ruin. Despite being charged with multiple felonies, he passes away before his incarceration. The question then arises: what inheritance does he leave for his family?

Reflecting on a similar real-life scenario, Kenneth Lay left a substantial portion of his wealth to his family. The exact figure remains to be determined, mainly because a significant portion was held in off-shore trusts beyond the reach of the American legal system. His assets included the entire 33rd floor of a high-rise and a $6 million apartment in Houston, designated as his homestead, which creditors could not claim.

This example underscores why, in Texas, your home is your most formidable asset protection tool. It effectively shields against two significant risks that can erode family wealth: creditor claims and long-term care expenses. Since 1846, the Texas Constitution has enshrined the unlimited homestead exemption, offering robust protection. However, it's essential to recognize that there are specific scenarios where one might lose this homestead protection.

Click here to speak with Taylor about asset protection.

Forced Sale of a Homestead in Texas: Understanding the Legal Framework

The Texas Constitution, specifically Section 50, offers robust protection for homesteads, shielding them from forced sale to satisfy debts, with limited exceptions. It states, “the homestead of a family, or a single adult person, shall be, and is hereby protected from forced sale, for the payment of all debts except for:” and then enumerates only eight specific exceptions. However, it's crucial to consider additional legal nuances that influence this protection.

To fully grasp the scope of homestead protection in Texas, one must acknowledge the continuation of the feudal landholding system, akin to a fief, in modern America. Under this system started by William the Conqueror, while one might hold fee-simple ownership – the most complete ownership form available – this right is always subject to certain governmental powers. These include the power of taxation, compulsory purchase (eminent domain), police powers, and the principle of escheat.

Moreover, restrictions or encumbrances from previous owners may impact property rights. For example, a Homeowners’ Association (HOA) might place specific conditions on the deed. These conditions could potentially lead to scenarios where the property could be subjected to forced sale despite the general protections offered by the homestead exemption in Texas. Understanding these layers of legal intricacies is essential for anyone seeking to navigate the complexities of property ownership and asset protection in Texas.

Evolution of Mortgage Regulations in the Texas Constitution

Since its inception in 1876, the Texas Constitution has undergone several amendments to accommodate mortgages on homestead properties. These provisions remained largely unchanged for nearly a century until 1973 when the constitution expanded its protection to include single adult homesteads and required mutual spousal consent to abandon a family homestead. The amendments since 1995 reflect a dynamic evolution in mortgage-related regulations:

1. 1995: The constitution was amended to allow homestead properties to be encumbered for debts arising from an owelty of partition or the refinancing of an existing lien.

2. 1997 and 1999: Amendments expanded the types of permissible liens for home equity loans, including provisions for reverse mortgages.

3. 2001: The constitution was revised to permit the forced sale of a homestead for debts incurred when a personal property lien, secured by a manufactured home, is converted into and refinanced as a real property lien. This amendment also revised deadlines related to the work and material exception in homestead protection.

4. 2003: Introduced the authorization of a home equity line of credit and provisions for the administrative interpretation of home equity lending laws. This amendment also allowed refinancing a home equity loan with a reverse mortgage.

5. 2005: Implemented additional methods and new restrictions for drawing line-of-credit advances under a reverse mortgage.

6. 2007: Clarified regulations concerning the origination of home equity loans and the utilization of proceeds from these loans.

7. 2013: Authorized reverse mortgage loans for purchasing homesteads and amended certain requirements related to reverse mortgage loans.

8. 2017: A lower cap on expenses charged to borrowers was established, and certain financing expense limitations for home equity loans were removed. It also defined specific authorized lenders for home equity loans, revised options for refinancing home equity loans, modified the threshold for advances on a home equity line of credit, and permitted home equity loans on agricultural homesteads.

These amendments highlight the evolving landscape of Texas mortgage and home equity loan regulations, reflecting changing economic conditions and lending practices.

Click here to speak with Taylor about asset protection.

What is the Best Asset Protection Tool in Texas?

The Texas homestead exemption is distinguished by its virtually unparalleled limits. Texas law does not cap the property's value that can be protected. Unlike other states where a dollar amount limits homestead protections, Texas safeguards the entire value of one's home, regardless of its worth. This means that whether your home is modest or a multi-million-dollar estate, it is equally shielded from most creditors. 

Consider the case of Kenneth Lay as an example: under Texas and Federal law, he was permitted to retain his home and bequeath it to his family. In contrast, other assets like IRAs and 401(k)s were liquidated for victim restitution following his criminal actions. It's a common belief that criminals should be held accountable and pay restitution, and rightly so in many instances. However, it's crucial to acknowledge situations where individuals are wrongfully convicted or found guilty of crimes they did not intend to commit. Imagine a scenario where the government erroneously sues you for failing to report your LLC under the Beneficial Ownership Information Report. Should your family suffer the consequences of poverty as a result? This highlights the importance of robust asset protection measures, like the homestead exemption in Texas, to safeguard your family's welfare against unforeseen legal challenges.

Expansive Acreage Coverage

Another significant advantage is the extent of land coverage. In urban areas, the exemption covers up to 10 acres of land, and in rural areas, this extends to 100 acres for an individual and 200 acres for a family. Other states rarely match this expansive coverage, and it is particularly beneficial for those with substantial land holdings.

Survivability and Family Protection

The homestead protection in Texas also extends beyond the homeowner's life. Spouses and minor children can continue to benefit from this exemption after the homeowner's death, ensuring that families are not left without a home due to the outstanding debts of the deceased.

Bankruptcy Advantages

In bankruptcy proceedings, the Texas homestead exemption offers significant advantages. Texans can choose between federal and state exemptions, often finding the state homestead exemption more beneficial. This choice provides a strategic advantage in preserving one's primary residence during bankruptcy.

Simple Requirements

The requirements to qualify for the homestead exemption in Texas are straightforward, making it accessible to most homeowners. The primary criteria are that the property must be the person's primary residence, and the homeowner must be an individual, not a corporation or other entity.

Medicaid and Long-Term Care Considerations

Under Medicaid regulations, a primary residence is not considered a countable asset. This is a crucial distinction, particularly compared to other qualified retirement accounts. While these retirement accounts are shielded from creditors under ERISA laws, they are considered countable assets for Medicaid eligibility purposes. It's important to note that the need for long-term care, rather than creditor issues, is often a more probable cause of significant wealth depletion.

Strategic Asset Protection Planning

In Texas, the primary residence is the foremost asset protection tool available. Nonetheless, individual circumstances vary, necessitating personalized strategies. It's essential to consult with a skilled advisor who can guide you through these complexities. Always seek the counsel of an attorney or financial advisor who is competent and maintains a reputation for honesty and integrity in their practice. Their expertise is invaluable in navigating the nuances of asset protection and long-term care planning.

Click here to speak with Taylor about asset protection.